List of the Top Disadvantages of the Electoral College 1. It does not always promote fairness. For the 6 months leading up to the 2016 election, polls consistently placed Hillary Clinton more than 10 points above Donald Trump in Washington State The debate over the continued use of the Electoral College resurfaced during the 2016 presidential election, when Donald Trump lost the general election to Hillary Clinton by over 2.8 million votes and won the Electoral College by 74 votes. The official general election results gave Trump 304 Electoral College votes and 46.09% of the popular vote (62,984,825), and Hillary Clinton received 227. The Pro's and Con's of the Electoral College System. There have, in its 200 year history, been a number of critics and proposed reforms to the Electoral College system - most of them trying to eliminate it. But there are also staunch defenders of the Electoral College who, though perhaps less vocal than its critics, offer very powerful.
. The Electoral College system was established by Article II of the U.S. Constitution in 1788. The Founding Fathers chose it as a compromise between allowing Congress to choose the president and having the president elected directly by the popular vote of the people. The Founders believed that most common citizens of the day were poorly educated and uninformed on. 1) when Electoral college system was established in 1789 it was a worry that if the system was abolished, the votes of their inhabitants would become worthless as larger states such as florid and California take priority
1) 11 elections between 1872 and 2012 the electoral college said to have seriously distorted results- e.g. Bill Clinton won 49% of population vote yet he won just over 70% of the electoral college vote 2)Hillary Clinton 2016- 47.7% of the vote and Donald Trump 47.5% of the population vot Amongst the weaknesses are: States with larger populations get more votes, thusly eliminating the voice of some of the smaller states; candidates can win the popular vote and still lose the election in two different ways, one being that there is no punishment for a member of the college who does not vote according to the popular vote in his/her state, and the other being that the candidate which wins the majority in a certain state will gain all the votes for that state What Are The Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Electoral College. A substantial amount of American citizens expected Hillary Clinton to win the presidential election over Donald Trump. Her popular votes exceeded over one million, however Donald Trump won the electoral college. So although Hillary won the popular vote, the people's vote, we have. What are the three main weaknesses of the electoral college system quizlet? what are the three main weaknesses of the electoral college? -winner of the popular vote is not guaranteed presidency. -electors are not required to vote in accord with the popular vote. -any election might have to be decided in the house of representatives . Individual Votes Don't Matter The idea of the electoral college isn't necessarily a bad one, but it does make each vote seemingly irrelevant
Unit 2 strengths vs. weaknesses of Electoral College System í ¼í¾“questionprevents a victory based solely on urban areas answerstrength questionhelps maintain the nations federal character answerstrengt However, in the Electoral College the same states account for 41 electoral votes. However this system has its flaws due to the fact that some states are solidly Democrat whilst others are solidly Republican, voters in these states are taken for granted resulting in little influence in the final result ..Analyse the strengths and weakness of the Electoral College (15 marks) The Electoral College is an old and complicated system set up by the Founding Fathers to elect the Executive branch. It was created in order to put a layer in the system of electing president as they did not fully trust democracy. As a result, the outcome of the president election is not determined by simply adding the. The Electoral College was created by the 1787 U.S. Constitutional Convention. With few changes, the EC was established to ensure the states are fairly represented in electing the president and. Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Electoral College. 841 Words4 Pages. The Electoral College has been disliked by many but also liked by other brilliant people in the United States. Some People have wanted to abolish the Electoral College. Former presidents and American leaders have thought that the Electoral College is a good way to take some.
What are the weaknesses of the electoral college system quizlet? what are the three main weaknesses of the electoral college? -winner of the popular vote is not guaranteed presidency. -electors are not required to vote in accord with the popular vote. -any election might have to be decided in the house of representatives The Strengths and Weaknesses of the Electoral College in the United States The electoral college is the system used to elect the president in the USA. There are several strengths of the system, such as that it ensures candidates campaign in a variety of states not just a few. There are also many weaknesses of the electoral college system; states can become safe seats; the result can be. There are three major flaws, or defects, in the electoral college system. First, there is always the danger that the winner of the popular vote will not win the presidency. This has happened four times, most recently in 2000. The winner-take-all factor mean
List of the Disadvantages of the Electoral College. 1. Some voters have more weight in the election than others do. Because the structure of the Electoral College is based on state population levels and representation in Congress, some voters have a ballot that carries more weight per delegate than others do POWER OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE AND THE WEAKNESSES OF THE NATIONAL POPULAR VOTE INTERSTATE COMPACT Daniel P. Rathbun* â€ Introduction The National Popular Vote (NPV) movement is designed to eliminate the federalist impact of the Electoral College without amending the Consti-tution It seems we need an electoral college in most African nations than the United States, most importantly in Nigeria to reduce Northern dominance and pursue a workable political system The Electoral College website now has an easy-to-remember address. Make sure to update your bookmarks! The Electoral College is a process, not a place. The Founding Fathers established it in the Constitution, in part, as a compromise between the election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens The central weakness of our political system right now is the Republican Party (like the Electoral College) for any party that does well in rural areas, and that allows Republicans to.
The first problem with the Electoral College is that it gives more weight to voters in small states than those in more populous ones, says DeRosa. Every state gets a minimum of three electoral votes. However, each state's total allotment is based on its representation in the Senate (always two people) and the House (varies by population) I have no doubt that, if we were to rewrite the Constitution today, we would not adopt the Electoral College system that we have. Our presidential election system is the byproduct of historical forces and political compromises made in 1787 that no longer have contemporary relevance or political resonanceâ€”gratefully, the nation no longer needs. As the turn of the century approached, America's budding love affair with political parties would soon expose the weaknesses of the original Electoral College system. The Election of 1800 One of the most important events in American history, the election of 1800 marked the first time an incumbent presidentâ€”one of the Founding Fathers at. Revise the variety of electoral systems used in the UK and their strengths and weaknesses as part of Bitesize Higher Modern Studies The second criticism of the Electoral College is the most challenging. One must defend the Electoral College not as perfect, but as a better solution than the alternative, i.e., direct popular election of the president. In very close elections, victory can be denied the candidate receiving the most popular votes nationwide
The electoral college is a compromise solution dating back to the origins of the country, when considerable concern existed that urban centres would dominate elections to the detriment of less. A. This spring, numerous candidates for president expressed support for either abolishing or changing the Electoral College, which ultimately picks the U.S. president. The National Archives reports that over the past 200 years more than 700 proposals have been introduced in Congress to reform or eliminate the Electoral College - without any becoming law
The Electoral College will put Donald Trump in the White House, even though he got swamped in the popular vote. Rex/AP. That raises another problem with the Electoral College: The founders never. Electoral College needs to be abolished and call for the establishment of the popular vote solely. The American Presidential system of votes is disproportionate, and every person should have an equal say in choosing his or her representatives (Ansolabehere, 2008, Pg. 25) Without Electoral College, getting the popular vote simply means a win. But with the electoral college, a candidate must get 270 votes from electors alone. This discourage people from participating in the polls . Conclusion. It is important to know the advantages and disadvantages of the Electoral College system to be able to weigh in on all.
The Voter Choice Ballot (VCB) is a new proposal for electoral college reform advocated by Making Every Vote Count. With enough 'yes' votes, a state acting under the VCB would award its electoral votes to the candidate who'd won the nationwide popular vote, contingent upon voters' responses to a ballot question Strengths and Weaknesses of the Electoral College . When the Electoral College was created, James Madison hoped it would avoid the silencing of minority opinions by an overly influential majority. Madison worried that factions might arise within the country that would harm the nation as a whole This idea, proposed by historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr., retains the current Electoral College system, but also awards extra electoral votes as a bonus to the winner of the popular vote. The amount suggested by Schlesinger in his National Bonus Plan is 102 extra electoral votes (two for every state and two for Washington, DC) What are three major weaknesses in the electoral college system? D.C. residents have no representation in the Senate. The Twenty-third Amendment, adopted in 1961, entitles the District to the same number of electoral votes as that of the least populous state in the election of the president and vice president Electoral College Reform. How to Keep, but Improve, the Current System. The Presidential election of 2000 served to highlight both the strengths and the weaknesses of the Electoral College and the essentially indirect method by which the citizens of the United States elect their Presidents
Abolishing the Electoral College and creating a national popular vote are far-fetched ideas for now. But there's a more targeted way to reform American elections by 2020â€”starting with the. Another potential weakness in the Electoral College system is the existence of so-called faithless electors, who for whatever reason choose to vote against their state's chosen candidate. So Wallace's candidacy was designed to deliberately exploit the weaknesses, the vulnerabilities, the quirks of the Electoral College system, it feels like, dating back all the way to the 3/5.
The Electoral College system also distinguishes the United States from other systems where the highest vote-getter automatically wins. This so-called indirect election process has been the subject of criticism and attempted reform, though proponents of it maintain that it ensures the rights of smaller states and stands as an important piece. The electoral college system comprises a complex mosaic of constitutional provisions, state and federal laws, and political party rules and practices. Although the electoral college system has delivered uncontested results in 46 out of 50 presidential elections since it assumed its present constitutional form in 1804, it has been the subject of. In translating votes into seats, MMP can be as proportional an electoral system as pure List PR, and therefore shares many of the previously cited advantages and disadvantages of PR. However, one reason why MMP is sometimes seen as less preferable than straight List PR is that it can give rise to what are called 'strategic voting' anomalies
In sum, the electoral system of the United States has both important disadvantages and important advantages. The disadvantages of the Electoral College are that elections become more 8 Advantages and Disadvantages of Electoral College, OccupyTheory.org, published July 29, 2014, accessed November 21, 2016 The Electoral College is a threat to our democracy. The process has become vulnerableâ€”independent or faithless electors could conceivably thwart the will of the voters for no clear reason. Although our founders felt we needed a brake against mob rule, it is incompatible with our current national credo that every vote counts
Passed by Congress December 9, 1803, and ratified June 15, 1804, the 12th Amendment provided for separate Electoral College votes for President and Vice President, correcting weaknesses in the earlier electoral system which were responsible for the controversial Presidential Election of 1800 An electoral college is defined as a body of representatives, chosen by popular vote, which formally elects the President and Vice-President of the United States ( Macmillan Dictionary ). This definition within itself explains how our present election system could fail. Representatives who actually vote for a President are chosen by popular vote by Raffi Piliero. Although enshrined in the Constitution by the founding fathers, the Electoral College has become a hot button issue over the past twenty years, attracting an ever greater number of defenders and detractors in recent years.. One hardly has to wonder why; twice in the past twenty years, the Electoral College has yielded a different result in a presidential election than the.
The United States uses an electoral college voting system to elect presidents. States contribute 538 electors, with a majority of 270 electors determining who wins the presidential election. The way that Donald Trump got elected shows some of the weaknesses that we have in the current system, and the weaknesses that the National Popular. What three events combined to change the intent of the original Electoral College System? What major change did the 12th? Amendment make in the Electoral College System? What are the three major weaknesses in the Electoral College System? Are there reform proposals? If so, which is the most widely supported
Recent Action onElectoral College Proposals. Read More; Electoral College Overview. How the Process Works. Read More; Issues for Debate. Strengths and Weaknesses of the Electoral College. Read More; Electoral College Reform. How to Keep, but Improve, the Current System. Read More; The 2000 Election. A Test of America's Democratic Systems. Read Mor The Electoral College was their answer. Because the system is written into the Constitution, an amendment would be required to alter the process. Like the Senate, the Electoral College helps to distribute power away from the most populated areas of the US. California gets 55 votes compared to Wyoming's 3, but this divide would be much greater. Dbq Essay On The Electoral College 904 Words | 4 Pages. This compromise helped give each state equal say in the government. As John Samples said to the Cato Institute in In Defense of the Electoral College, the Electoral College makes sure that the states count in presidential elections an important part of our federalist system - a system worth preserving federalism is central. ELECTORAL COLLEGE VOTING SYSTEM Critique/analyze the Electoral College Electoral College voting system applies to the election of the president and the vice president. It is a system whereby votes are granted to each state based on its representation in congress. their weaknesses in these advertisements to create a perfect figure for.
As Congress meets in Joint Session today to formally receive and count the Electoral College votes, CLC President Trevor Potter and Harvard Law Professor Charle... s Fried, who served as solicitor general under President Ronald Reagan and is a member of CLC's board of directors, have written an op-ed in The New York Times about the weaknesses in the Electoral College system revealed by this. Flag this paper! This research paper will be informative about the Electoral College and it's operations, historical. development, weaknesses of the system, and proposed changes. This paper will go into the. depths of how and why it is still in use to this day. The purpose is to report to the voters of this Andrew Prokop added that the final tallies further spotlight the glaring weaknesses in our country's bizarre, anachronistic Electoral College system that have long been evident.Making matters. stance on welfare spending. This argument gives the electorate little credit; however, there are also real fears for the future of political communication. These fears relate to the fact that all that may separate the parties is their ability to package themselves. That as the culture of political communication changes, then the public will increasingly judge parties and governments on the way.
The Electoral College is the number of votes which determines the outcomes of a US presidential race. There are a number of criticisms of this election process. The main one is that disbursement of votes may not always accurately represent the popular vote. Several presidential elections, notably the 2000 Bush versus Gore, have resulted in a. Advantages of the Electoral College. 1. Helps Prevent a Recount. By using the Electoral College you are ensuring that the results of the election are certain, for the most part. Recounts of millions of votes can take a very long time and cost a large amount of money. The Electoral College greatly helps to prevent this At issue is the uniquely American system of the Electoral College, which provides that a group of specially chosen representatives (538 at present) for each state choose the president, generally.
E ven the best political systems cannot eliminate corruption, venality, and civil strife, but they are supposed to limit their sway. Enshrined in the U.S. Constitution, the American electoral system was designed to do that, yet the recent presidential election has revealed serious weaknesses in the way a president is chosen The Electoral College system governing us today, as delineated in the 12th Amendment, is primarily the result of congressional deliberations in 1803, which revised the original system adopted at. It is a corruption of all the fundamental ideas of a democratically elected government in the modern day and age. The electoral college arbitrarily weights votes based on which side of an imaginary line people live on. In general, if the populatio.. and legal weaknesses of the electoral college. Most importantly, Ross gets one key question right: she argues that when assessing the electoral college versus one-man-one-vote (or against any other insti-tutional alternative), our assessment should focus on more than equality between individual voters
gress to simplify and correct the weaknesses which soon became ap-parent in the electoral college. Only the twelfth amendment, passed in 1803 and ratified in 1804, has effected any major revision. The present electoral college system is an archaic system, one that contains the potential for many undemocratic resolutions of. In the Electoral College system, the States serve as the Centurial groups (though they are not, of course, based on wealth), and the number of votes per State is determined by the size of each State's Congressional delegation. Still, the two systems are similar in design and share many of the same advantages and disadvantages Pros of Electoral College. The system tends to represent more the diversity of the country. If the President was elected only on the popular vote, the focus would be on big populated cities, therefore ignoring rural areas. The Electoral College is also the reflection of the federal character of the United States The Founders set up our delicate system of choosing elected officials, including the electoral college, after much study and debate with full knowledge of its strengths and weaknesses. And with only minor modifications over the past 220 years, this system has served the nation extremely well